When does it make sense to buy another company to grow?

When does it make sense to buy another company to grow?
Growing is one of the main priorities of any company. But when a business wants to increase its size, enter new markets, expand its offering or incorporate new capabilities, a fundamental strategic decision arises:
by Jordi Trunas

Header: growing by acquiring another company

Is it better to build that growth internally or accelerate it by acquiring another company?

An acquisition can allow a company to achieve in months what would organically take years. But it also requires capital, increases organisational complexity and introduces risks that do not exist —or exist to a lesser degree— in organic growth.

That is why, before considering an acquisition, the question should not be “can we buy this company?”, but rather:

“Does buying this company generate more value than continuing to grow through our own means?”

Build vs. Buy: two ways of reaching the same goal

Imagine an industrial company with €15 million in revenue that wants to enter a new geographic area.

It can choose to open a branch office, hire a sales team and progressively win new clients. Or it can acquire a local company that already has clients, a team, market knowledge and positioning.

The goal is the same. The path is not.

Build vs Buy: two paths to the same goal

Organic growth Acquisition
Speed Progressive Immediate
Initial investment Generally lower Generally high
Financial risk Lower Higher
Execution risk Commercial development Acquisition + integration
Process control High Depends on integration
Access to clients Must be acquired Acquired with the deal
Talent and capabilities Must be developed Incorporated
Impact on results Progressive Can be immediate

There is no universally better alternative.

The decision depends on cost, time required, risk and, above all, the ability of each option to generate a return on invested capital.

A particularly useful question is: How many years would we need to build internally what we are considering buying at lower risk?

If replicating a given client portfolio, production capacity, team or market positioning would take four or five years, paying to incorporate it immediately may well make sense.

What are we really buying?

A company is not just its revenue and EBITDA.

When we acquire a business we may be buying a client portfolio that is difficult to replicate, recurring contracts, talent, technology, production capacity, a commercial network, an established brand or a specific competitive position.

That is why any acquisition should be grounded in a clear strategic thesis.

Management should be able to explain in a few sentences:

What will the group have after the acquisition that it does not have today?

If the answer is simply “more revenue” or “more EBITDA”, the strategic rationale of the deal probably needs to be thought through more carefully.

5 criteria to determine whether an acquisition makes sense

Before progressing with a deal, there are five aspects that should be analysed together.

1. Strategic fit

The target company must bring something that accelerates the buyer’s strategy: clients, geography, product, technology, talent, production capacity or positioning.

The first question must always be why this company?

2. Price and expected return

A good company can be a bad investment if the price paid is excessive.

It is not enough to compare the acquisition multiple against other market transactions. It is necessary to understand what return the investment will generate, taking into account growth, cash generation, synergies and future capital needs.

3. Realistic synergies

Synergies can come from revenue —cross-selling, new clients or channels— or from costs —procurement, overheads, logistics or systems—.

But only those that are identifiable, quantifiable and executable should be incorporated into the investment case.

4. Financial capacity

The company must be able to absorb both the purchase price and the subsequent needs of integration and growth.

A strategically attractive acquisition can become a problem if it leaves the group with an excessively stretched financial structure.

5. Integration capacity

Finally, one must ask whether the organisation is ready to absorb another company.

Integrating people, processes, systems, clients and corporate cultures requires management resources. Especially in Buy & Build strategies, this capacity becomes a critical factor.

Synergies: where value is created —or destroyed

A significant part of an acquisition’s potential value comes from synergies.

As an example; suppose a company generating €3M of EBITDA is studying the acquisition of a competitor with €1M of EBITDA.

The agreed price is €5 million:

Enterprise Value = €1M EBITDA × 5x = €5M

Without considering any other variable, the resulting group would generate €4M of EBITDA.

But during analysis, €300,000 per year of realistic synergies are identified between cost savings and commercial opportunities.

The combined EBITDA could therefore reach:

€3M + €1M + €0.3M = €4.3M

From the buyer’s perspective, the €5 million invested is effectively incorporating €1.3 million of additional EBITDA.

That is equivalent to an approximate multiple of:

€5M / €1.3M = 3.8x EBITDA

The economic reading of the deal changes substantially.

But there is a fundamental condition: the €300,000 of synergies must actually materialise.

“A synergy that only exists in the financial model does not create value.”

Synergies: when the whole is worth more than the sum of its parts

Buying well is as important as buying a good company

One of the most common mistakes in M&A is falling in love with the asset.

A company can have strong positioning, grow, generate cash and have an excellent team. But that does not mean any price is justified.

In many transactions, the value of the company is initially determined by applying a multiple to EBITDA:

Enterprise Value = EBITDA × multiple

But the multiple should not be the only reference point.

The buyer should also analyse:

  • The conversion of EBITDA into cash.
  • CAPEX requirements.
  • The working capital needed to grow.
  • Revenue recurrence.
  • Client concentration.
  • Existing debt.
  • Dependence on key individuals.
  • Potential synergies.
  • Expected return on investment.

Ultimately, the multiple tells us how much we are paying. The return tells us whether it makes sense to pay it.

Buy & Build: when acquisitions become a strategy

In certain sectors, buying a company is not a one-off transaction, but the start of a consolidation strategy.

A Buy & Build strategy consists of using one company as a platform and progressively incorporating other complementary businesses.

This model is especially interesting in fragmented markets with many small and medium-sized companies.

The logic is to acquire companies, integrate them and progressively build a group with greater scale, more commercial capacity, a professionalised structure and better diversification.

Beyond operational synergies, a second effect can emerge: multiple arbitrage.

For example, a group could acquire several small companies at valuations of 4–5x EBITDA and build a consolidated business that, by virtue of its scale, diversification, recurrence and professionalisation, could come to be valued at 7–8x EBITDA.

However, it is important not to take this increase for granted.

Putting companies together does not automatically create a higher-quality group.

Buy and Build: growing by incorporating complementary companies

The higher multiple will only make sense if the resulting group is genuinely better: more diversified, less dependent on individual shareholders, with better reporting, greater revenue recurrence, more cash generation capacity and a management structure ready to continue growing.

Deal structure also creates value

An acquisition does not necessarily have to be paid entirely in cash on the day of signing.

There are different mechanisms to structure a transaction:

  • Bank debt, if cash generation allows it to be serviced.
  • Private debt, when a more flexible structure is needed.
  • Vendor loan, when the seller finances part of the price.
  • Earn-out, when part of the price depends on future results.
  • Seller reinvestment, when the seller retains a minority stake in the resulting group.

An appropriate structure can reduce the initial capital required, align buyer and seller and improve the return on invested capital.

But the objective should not be to maximise debt.

The right question is:

What level of debt can the group comfortably absorb if results are 10% or 20% below projections?

A structure that only works in the optimistic scenario is, in all likelihood, too aggressive.

Integration: where the deal is really won

Closing is not the end of an acquisition — it is the beginning.

Many transactions have sound strategic and financial rationale, but fail to generate the expected value because integration is not executed correctly.

People, culture, IT systems, commercial processes, financial reporting, pricing policy and client relationships are some of the elements that need to be managed.

That is why the integration plan should begin before closing.

The first 100 days should have very concrete objectives:

  • Retain key people.
  • Protect the most important clients.
  • Establish governance and responsibilities.
  • Integrate financial reporting.
  • Define which processes will be unified.
  • Assign ownership to each synergy.
  • Set KPIs to measure the integration.

If no one is accountable for a synergy, it is unlikely to ever materialise.

The most common mistakes

Although every deal is different, certain mistakes appear repeatedly.

  • Overpaying. A good company does not justify any valuation.
  • Overestimating synergies. Especially commercial ones, which tend to be harder to execute than cost synergies.
  • Failing to analyse the quality of EBITDA. Earnings can be affected by extraordinary items, underinvestment, client concentration or adjustments that will not be sustainable.
  • Forgetting cash flow. EBITDA and cash are not the same thing.
  • Underestimating integration. Absorbing a company consumes management resources.
  • Taking on too much debt. An aggressive financial structure dramatically reduces the margin for error.
  • Buying opportunities rather than executing a strategy. The fact that a company is for sale does not mean it is right for our group.

An acquisition must begin with a thesis, not a target

An acquisition can allow a company to transform itself: enter a market, incorporate capabilities, increase scale or consolidate a sector. But buying a company is not an end in itself — it is a tool for executing a strategy.

Before starting to look for potential targets, any management team should be able to answer three questions:

  • What do we want to achieve?
  • Why is buying better than building it internally?
  • What return do we expect to obtain on the invested capital?

Only then does it make sense to start talking about targets, multiples and financing structures.

An acquisition begins long before finding the company we want to buy.

“A good M&A strategy is not about buying companies. It is about using acquisitions to build a better company.”